|
||
|
Rarely does a
single
novelist
cast such a shadow over an entire topic in a genre of fiction. If
one asks for a list of mainstream historical novels on Alexander
the Great, or even on ancient Greece, the reply is usually some
variation
on, "You have read Mary Renault, haven't you?" With good
reason.
Even if one wishes to quibble with details or characterizations,
Renault
managed to capture the feel of ancient Greece as well or better than
any
other novelist to date. That doesn't mean a "New Renault" won't
emerge
in the future, yet for the moment, she reigns supreme as the queen of
Greek
historical fiction. In fact, the
impact of
Renault
may be somewhat responsible for the relative dearth of fictional works
on this enigmatic personality dubbed Alexander Magnus by the
Romans
and who was, arguably, the most famous non-religious figure prior to
the
20th Century. Comparisons to Renault are unavoidable, and authors
(and publishers) may prefer not to run the risk of being "almost
Renault."
(Lest I be thought to exaggerate, consider the plethora of books on
King
Arthur, Julius Caesar, or even Robin Hood.) The list collected here records fiction published from about 1920 forward, in which Alexander is -- if not the protagonist -- then at least a significant figure. (Although in a few, such as Mary Renault's Funeral Games, his "presence" is largely posthumous.) Many of the books have reviews, as I've been collecting Alexander fiction for some years and have read (in fact, own) most of these works. The reviews focus on two aspects which I consider essential to fine historical fiction: good writing and good history. It's not enough just to spin a compelling yarn; one should also practice the art of getting the details right. But by the same token, if dry historical accuracy is all one seeks, one may as well read non-fiction. The best authors -- the Renaults -- do both. Text
c1997-2005, Jeanne
Reames Top 5% award from "Alexander the Great on the Web" |